Though she did admit to finding her "Phil of the Future" costar cute during those days. Sorry, Phil and Keely fans: Aly Michalka shut down rumors that she dated her ...

There was definitely a crush early on — at least on Aly's side — but as AJ pointed out, Ullman — who went by Ricky during his time on the show — is "older" than Aly. "That age range felt huge.